A High-Stakes Gamble, In China and the U.S.

A long post on China Financial Markets brings a timely reminder not to get too euphoric about the recent turbo-charged economic numbers - everything from bank lending to car sales took a big jump in the first quarter - regardless of the official cheerleading. Key to whether China's economy is really recovering is whether all that money is creating jobs. Hard to know - but as the blog points out, even among officials there is the realization that the stimulus plan's impact could be temporary and a second round could still be necessary.
Meanwhile, in the U.S., talk of a second stimulus package - mooted as recently as in February - has all but withered away as the economy appears to have stopped falling in a straight line. That's no grounds for complacency, though - while China might see a W-shaped recovery, the risk in the U.S. is an L-shaped one (though U remains the favored forecast, for now).
China needs, as CFM notes, to see more private than public sector growth - but that doesn't seem to be happening, if the numbers quoted are correct. It still needs a prospering export industry, even as it seeks to reduce its dependency on foreign demand and become more reliant on domestic consumption. All the while, there's the issue of its massive foreign exchange reserves and how to manage them.
The U.S. problems are just as daunting: it has to do the reverse of the Chinese - reduce consumer demand and become more competitive in the global market place; it also has to reduce the share of its financial industry (which even last year accounted for 28% or so of domestic corporate profits) in the overall economy and find something to replace the lost business with. As consumer demand shrinks, Americans' reliance on debt should also diminish - doing away with the need for the securitization markets which lie at the heart of the financial crisis and which the authorities seem hellbent on restoring - even though if we've learnt one thing, it's the fallacy of the grandiose notion of democratizing credit.
The point is this: the Leviathans of the global economy - China and the U.S. - are both facing wrenching structural changes. Both governments are working on making the changes bearable and limiting the pain to their populations, but let's be realistic: it's a high-stakes gamble - there are no blue prints; plus the sobering thought that the last time we got out of a similar economic desaster, the world was engulfed in warfare.