Is The PPIP Pure Piffle?

Pity Timothy Geithner - it seems that no plan that bears his imprint will ever meet the approval of the nattering nabobs. At least today, he has the comfort of having won the blessing - albeit temporary - of the markets.

But is his plan as bad as the critics claim? Does it really fail to address the key issue, as some say -namely that it's the state of the banks as a whole, not that of certain groups of assets (home loans, commercial real estate etc.) that needs to be addressed? That some banks are just in such bad shape that they need to be nationalized, then wound down - and that the Treasury's public-private investment program is just postponing the day of reckoning?

What the critics overlook is that the financial markets are still a train wreck. True, the stock market is up. Also true, investment-grade bond issuance is at a record for the current quarter. But equally true is that Asian investors have packed up and left the mortgage-backed securities market - and they aren't about to return. Private label mortgages - ones not guaranteed by the government in the form of Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac guarantees - are moribund, commercial real estate is in dire state - and a lot of those loans and securities sit on bank balance sheets. We aren't out of the woods yet; it's just that the markets that are visible have picked up some. And let's not forget the reason for that wasn't pontificating, it was vigorous government and central bank action. Meantime, starved of the oxygen of finance, the global economy is heading toward a full-scale recession this year.

So the Geithner plan is first and foremost a plan to help restart markets that, more than 18 months into the crisis, are still not working (remember, it was the early August 2007 admission by BNP that it was temporarily freezing three investment vehicles because it wasn't possible to value the asset-backed securities these vehicles held that got the ball rolling) and are doing untold harm to the economy. The key goal is to get private capital moving again.

Certainly, the signs are auspicious for the one leg of the Treasury's plan, the auction process for wholesale loans held by banks. As to the other leg, the one dealing with securities backed by home loans and commercial real estate loans, that will take a while to get going. But what the plan does do is get the credit machine rolling again. It will help the banks too, chiefly by buying them time to get their house in order.

Some banks could still fail - we are still in the thick of the woods. It's to be hoped that Congress makes good use of the room that Treasury has created to come up with a legislative framework for the bankruptcy and unwinding of a large financial institutions. It's been a year since Bear Stearns hit the skids - and the absence of such a framework became painfully obvious.